Index To Site


HOME



PRIVATE PRACTICE

Services Offered by
appointment for individuals,
couples and groups.


COMMUNITY WORKSHOPS

Providing a focused
means for participants to
explore differing aspects of
their lives and their selves.


About PAUL CHIRUMBOLO

A summary of training
and experience plus what
others have said of his work.


_______________________________
DREAM WORK SERIES
Select writings of interest

The Dreamworld Descent
Psyche, Self and Soul Retrieval
Digging For Gold In
The Underworld

Inner Wisdom and Creative Resources
Quick Sudden Shifts
And Fast Moving Turns

Imaginal States of Awareness
The Kaleidoscope Set To Whirl Transforming Yourself and Your World

_______________________________
GAY STUDIES SERIES
Select writings of interest

The Biopsychophysics Of Gaiety
Mythological Antecedents and Gods
Two-Spirit Native People
Sex, Gods and Gay People Underlying The Myths
The Garden Of Adam & Steve
Bibliography


_______________________________
WESTERN PSYCHOLOGY SERIES
Select writings of interest

A Return To Idland
Psychic Reality, Sexual Fantasy,
and Its Unconscious Source

Posttraumatic Stress Disorder
An Integrative Approach
Symbolic Imagination
Understanding Treatment of Children Through Fairy Tale and Play
The Ugly Duckling
Fairy Tale as Metaphor For The Understanding and Treatment of Gay Men
Gay Child Development


_______________________________
PRINCIPLES OF MAKING CHANGE
Select writings of interest

Shedding The Old Skin
A Necessary Pre-requisite To Any New Birth
Enacting Sacred Drama
Clearing The Field For Something New

Giving Form To Inspired Thought
Creating New Life
Embodying Your Desires
Offering Thanks and Letting Go


_______________________________
GAY MEN'S DREAM SERIES
Select writings of interest

The Two Davids
Even Chickens Dream


Upcoming:
The Man Of Your Dreams
Dueling Baggage
The Ants Have Trapped The Spider
The Secret
... and more!








































































































































































































































































































































Return To TOP
 
 



PSYCHIC REALITY, SEXUAL FANTASY
and ITS UNCONSCIOUS SOURCE


The Unconscious Source of Projections

When in the 1890's Sigmund Freud developed his theories of development he forced people to consider that sexuality does not suddenly appear at puberty, but exists from the moment of birth. He thus inextricably linked the human condition with what he called unconscious libidinal drives; for the infant, a mass of seething uncontrolled urges, pushing and pulling in any direction, seeking erotic bodily pleasure.

In essence this search for a physical and emotional rapture could be called a kind of infantile foreplay, and Freud localized it in the oral, anal, and phallic erotogenic zones. The pleasure of suckling for the new born child, quite apart from assuaging its hunger pangs, served as a solvent of isolation, the first temptation in a four-fold movement towards ego development and away from the undifferentiated paradisiacal state. Soon divorced from the whole of life, a psychical wholeness encompassing all of what Freud called the Id, the child becomes an adult.1

Melanie Klein, herself an adherent to the tenets of psychoanalytic thought, redefined some of Freud's schemata - put it on fast forward, so to speak. According to Kleinian theory, the newborn child arrives with an already existent, albeit primitive, ego just waiting to unfold. And when thrust out into the whole of the world outside the mother's womb, it begins doing just that in the form of a spate of unconscious primitive fantasies about every aspect of its new life. The baby instinctively focuses on pleasurable sensations as "good," part of a projective process of identification in order to localize itself. At the same time the little ego engages in splitting off whatever "bad" fantasies the baby cannot hold (e.g. the fear of annihilation) casting them outside the sphere of its own as yet unformed awareness of itself in order to survive.

It is expected that the mother will be capable of receiving these infantile projections, and of transforming them into something that is quite usable in return, such as when the baby's "bad" hunger pangs are soothed by the mother's cooing while the need for food itself is eliminated by taking in milk from the mother's breast. Thus sated with psychosomatic pleasure, the infantile needs are met.

It is rooted in these earliest encounters that projection as a psychological process is formed. That is, as part ofa pattern of projective identification, the child assumes something about the receptacle of its projections that has less to do with the other and more to do with itself.

For those unfortunate individuals who became "fixed" at any of the infantile stages (and we all have to greater or lesser degree), Freud posited that they would develop maladaptive traits corresponding to whatever level they were stuck at. Object relations theory similarly suggests that when the baby's infantile needs are not satisfactorily met, it will carry the same ongoing demands into adulthood. They are often dissociated from adult life experience, however, and, as motivating factors, are stored outside of conscious awareness. It is these unconscious fixations, or unmet infantile drives, which become activated in the course of intimate adult relations and, like a pinball set against the bumpers, start bouncing madly about. Indeed, the aura of such adult experience is said to reconstitute the infantile psychological, emotional, and sexual fantasies first linked together as part of the original mother-child state, and they are then transferred to the adult's partner. As such, transference - the means whereby individuals project onto others the repressed hopes, fears, questions, and conflicts of their past - also enters into the intimacy of the therapeutic encounter, as well. The patient's unfinished business, as it were, produces a distortion in the way the patient perceives and reacts to their therapist, often times as if they were retumed to sit face-to-face with one big breast, ready to have it out.

When the transference takes on a sexual charge, the erotic feelings can similarly be found rooted in the very same infantile expectations; that is, the glimmer of erotogenic expectation coresponds to an unconscious hope that unmet needs from long ago will, at long last, be put to rest.


SEXUAL FANTASY ~ A Gay Perspective

I am a gay man. I have conducted workshops and participated in a variety of other such settings, seeing both men and women, for the past 14 years. I can recall particular instances when women in my workshops have projected onto me the characteristics of an all knowing, all powerful expert, something of a seer. Yet, for me, while the transference was very real, it never specifically engaged a sexual countertransference or response. It's been quite different, however, working with men, gay men in particular.

Under the rubric "coming out inside," I have worked with issues of internalized homophobia, as well as other elements of self discovery and personal growth.2

Inherent in the work is a waking up of repressed or otherwise displaced creative energy, including (though not limited to) the individual's homosexuality. Taking someone under your wing in this context almost always elicits a response, sometimes what could even be called a "father hunger," often transferred with a highly erotic charge.3 By using the term "father hunger," however, I do not mean to imply a "fixed" stage developmental determinant for homosexuality. Indeed, I believe that when psychoanalytic theory reduces development in the gay child to a perversion of the so-called heterosexual norm, it confuses gay child development with a heterosexist bias, rendering incomprehensible what is otherwise an already innate potential - gaiety - of which homosexuality is but a part.3 While seemingly afield from a look at sexual transference, it is not. For "father hunger," as I am using it here, is the archetypal sense of an awakening generative masculinity, distinct from the reproductive model, yet nonetheless libidinal in its source.

Such a force is itself often thwarted by a constellation of a different sort, the Puer Eternis (or eternal youth). As a carrier of creative imagination, the Puer embodies exciting possibilities, and it exerts a powerful influence in the psyche, particularly the gay psyche. Yet without the presence of an equally influential counterpart, the archetypal father, the gay child can often become lost, finding it nearly impossible to fulfill his creative promise. And so he presents himself for the therapeutic encounter. In order to turn the creative potential into an equally fertile life, the pleasure principal, girded by his rising generativity, must be sublimated.4

I am, of course, referring to a need to re-vision the Oedipal Complex for the requirements of the gay child (instead of the other way around), for it's a little wrong-footed to refer to the experience of the mythological King of Thebes when speaking of gay child development. Indeed, when gay child development turns to the assignments of Freud's Oedipal phase, much of psychosexual theory as we know it must be turned upside down.5 That's not to say that the gay baby goes out with the bath water, so to speak, for by enlivening this "father hunger" it similarly touches into childhood, engendering the same renewed hopes formerly embodied in infantile drives, including sexual fantasy. And so, when in the course of the therapeutic encounter the appearance of "father hunger" makes its way out as an erotic response, it is likewise in reality something far beyond somebody simply trying to get into somebody else's pants.


PSYCHIC REALITY

I would suggest it goes farther than mere comprehension, however. Indeed, one of the great achievements of psychology has been the way it has reintroduced to the world what the religious, mystical and esoteric schools of East and West have always taught. In shamanism and the yogic traditions, for example, interpsychic powers such as psychic diagnosis, clairvoyant perceptions of energy fields, telepathy, and the like are commonly induced, peeling back the skin of ordinary reality to gain access to an otherwise nonordinary awareness, thereby penetrating to the psychic root of psychological problems - namely, the basically dualistic notion of the ego or a separate self.

This is not so very different at all from what D. W. Winnicott, another of the post-Freudian object-relations theorists, conceived of in terms of a "primary maternal preoccupation." Entered into a state of heightened sensitivity, it represents the mother's capacity to relinquish her own ego and totally open to the presence of the infant in a way that would otherwise be labeled psychotic. Similar to the baby, in a state of absolute dependence and not yet able to modify its own pain without the mediating influence of its caregiver, the patient enters the therapist's office to re-create this scene. Moreover, just as it is expected that the mother will be capable of receiving the infantile projections, and of transforming them in return, so too does a requisite responsibility fall upon the therapist as something of a midwife attending a psychological (re)birth. It can be likened to when the yogis, for example, are referred to as "taking on the karma" of their disciples to help them overcome their problems. And, bearing similar dynamics when enacted as part of the countertransference, it is but a variety of the common shamanic technique of healing by way of a "sympathetic resonance" with the patient's problem, reflecting the ancient belief that the shaman cannot treat any "illness" he does not "know" himself.9


RETURN TO IDLAND

It is perhaps only in recent times that it has become clearer that Freud's psychosexual explanations, or the maladaptations which grow out of unmet infantile needs, (while certainly playing their part) do not satisfactorily account for all of what is at work when Eros flies into the therapist's room. That is, a deeper human hunger seems to lie underneath the levels of being which Freud, Klein, Winnicott, and others were so concerned with.

When the ancient Greek philosophers Plato and Aristotle began their systematic study of human states of mind, they did so in the sense of a concept of psychology as found in its original Greek form. Exploring "psyche," what was used to denote the state of being alive, they were investigating the life force itself. It has been called throughout the whole of human history by different names worldwide. Whereas Freud talked about the libido, the Polynesians call it mana; the Siouan Lakota: wakanda. Hindus refer to prana; and the ancient Egyptians called it ka.

In the Greek pantheon of understanding the human condition, the original Eros, one of the oldest of the androgynous gods, was a representative of this awe-inspiring universal force. Similar to Freud's psychosexual explanations, it was conceived in terms of sexuality; yet it was seen as less of an end unto itself and more a means to something quite more. Take by way of another example the androgynous love goddess Aphrodite. She was said to have been "born from the foam which boiled up when the severed genitals of the sky god Uranus were thrown into the sea." It doesn't take much of a leap to understand foam boiling up as semen, and the severed genitals as the spent erection, and, as a result of such an orgasm, the mind is cast into the sea of an undifferentiated state of awareness,l0 suggesting that the real goal of sexual activity may not merely be procreation or even infantile erotic pleasure (as divine as that may be) but something more akin to the blissful union with the life force itself, a return to Idland, so tos peak, but re-created when the patient is held in the throes of their therapist's reverie.

I don't mean to diminish or deny the very real presence of the psychodynamics at work in the projection of infantile fantasy. But inasmuch as psychology is born less out of the materialism of science, but of the sacred, it is by accessing this state of consciousness (in which we recognize there truly is no "other" - dictates of the ego aside) that we continually inform life of such, and we gain the wisdom required to evolve and change. And so, to mediate the appearance of sexual transference and countertransference, the challenge may be not only to learn developmental theory as useful sign posts along the way, as well as cognitive behavioral interventions to assist in guiding the charge, but also how to dance in the light of the sun, the moon, the stars, et al to help bridge the divide as a means to truly reforming the patient's mind, and thereby help them get on with life.

End
A RETURN TO IDLAND

Full Citations Follow



FOOTNOTES: Full Citations

A Return To Idland

  1. As the father of psychoanalysis, Sigmund Freud can be ranked with Charles Darwin and Albert Einstein as one of the giants of the last 200 years. His work radically changed Western thought about the human condition, its environment, and the relationship between the two. Yet in some way he outlined but a partial truth and made it look more like the universal state of things itself. That is, Freud's seeming over-emphasis on a sexual interpretation for nearly every human motive, from infancy on, may have stopped him just short of the gate, so to speak. You see, on a personal level, Freud was also a puritanical and inhibited man and, if nothing else, perhaps spoke out of his own inexperience in regards to the transcendent function (indeed, for that underlies his construct of the super ego). And so, he had to cling to some of the baser things. It's as if Freud never experienced the resurrection himself, never carried aloft to the mystical heavens, and away from his more psycho-sexually constructed definition of life. I don't mean to sound so glib. Indeed, Freud himself may have cut short his own growing interest in such a fascination because it would have interfered with the organization of his theories. In a letter late in life to the psychical researcher Hereward Carrington, he went so far as to say: 'If I had my life to live over again I should devote myself to psychical research rather than psychoanalysis.'"

  2. "Coming Out Inside," as a term for a stage in gay identity development, was first coined by Mark Thompson as the title of an essay he penned. I was first introduced to the process by Donald Kilhefner by participating in workshops he conducted under the same name. Similarly, Don Kilhefner first began utilizing the term "father hunger" as part of the gay-centered work he offers as a Jungian psychologist in private practice. While my use of the term does not strictly conform to Kilhefner's work under the same name, I am nonetheless indebted to him for introducing me to these processes. Regarding my examples in the text, with younger guys especially, there's usually a lot of unfocused sexual energy flying about anyway. With this, I am not referring to seductive behavior, nor do I believe it is necessarily the projective processes at work. It has more to do with a "genuine" and heightened adult male physicality typical for that age. I guess we call that hormones.

  3. When psychoanalysis outlines a theory of infantile sexuality for how gender identification and the sexual object is formed, it does so within the framework of a cultural bias which sees the reproductive model, essentially as realized through heterosexual marriage, as its so-called norm. Marital sexuality thus becomes the symbol of creativity and, thereby, only heterosexual orientation is considered innate. It's important to note that this presumptive heterosexism is rooted essentially in religious doctrine. The late Paul Monette put it neatly when he said "Patriarchal systems, such as the Roman Catholic Church, are terrified by gay people and our history, because we are what they only pretend to be."

  4. When discussing sublimation of libidinal (psychosexual) energy, it's interesting to draw comparisons to the related fields of energy medicine and yoga. Each places emphasis on the awareness and understanding of energy fields localized in certain centers roughly corresponding to parts of the human body - energy centers most familiarly called chakras. The base or "lowest" chakra is ordinarily related to survival needs and reproduction, found located between the genitalia and the anus. In the physical practice of hatha yoga, as a means to balance the energy flow throughout all the chakras, it is not unusual for a male to achieve an instant erection (without the intrusion of sexual fantasies or thought forms) as the energy becomes activated and first flows into the base chakra. As the yoga regimen continues by taking different postures related to "exercising" the other chakras, the penis grows flaccid accompanied by the experience of a more altered or creative state of consciousness; that is, the sexual energy has been sublimated in its movement throughout the entire human energy field.

  5. It is beyond the scope of this paper to reconfigure Freud's formulation of the Oedipal phase of identity formation for the purposes of gay child development. For the gay child, subtle, less conscious processes have already been at work, for sure, e.g. the lack of mirroring responsiveness, in which the gay child's expressions are dimly recognized in the form of some primitive discomfort, interpreted as injurious to the parent's sense of well-being. The father's uncomfortable reactions, especially, to the gay child are particularly confusing, with the father withdrawing at unexplained moments, repeated over and over again. Worse, such original experiences take place on a level of being not yet available for preconscious or conscious interpretation or integration. At the same time, unlike being Black or Jewish, for example, the gay child is also typically alone with his "differentness," as well as unclear and confused by "it," increasingly conflicted by the outer world's response to "it," and ultimately horrified by "it." So "it" begins to be fearfully avoided. While in some ways similar to Freud's theoretical musings (in that the penis symbolizes generative power), it is actually quite different from the threat of having your penis literally cut off. That is, the Oedipal assignment as described in psychoanalytic theory becomes a neat little construct of dubious origins for the gay child to internalize homophobia. More than rendering the Oedipal passage almost irrelevant for the gay child, much as when, in incomprehension, Freud himself referred to women, finally, as "the dark continent", it serves as a pathogenic prescription for much harm to be done to the gay self.

  6. Harmell, Pamela Hersh, "The Effects of Therapist Self-Awareness on Countertransference" reprinted in Antioch University Los Angeles Course Reader: PSY 548 Professional Ethics and the Law, p. 172.

  7. The phenomenon of countertransference is something much discussed, particularly as a hindrance to the therapeutic encounter. Indeed, resolution of the analyst's conflicts is not the goal of treatment, nor do I believe they should be resolved in such relationships. Others spin off in a tactical discussion of the degrees to which the interference interposes, formulating methods to analyze and reverse the effects. Freud himself went so far as to call for a "psychoanalytic purification" as preparation for the analyst. Yet therapists are human, too, and the enactment of the transference and the countertransference are part and parcel of a normal and natural interpersonal event. Awareness of the countertransference (and thereby awareness of one's self) serves as a useful guide to therapeutic relationships and thereby helps the patient. It's quite another matter, however, if resistance to the patient's transference becomes an impediment to the process. If this came about during the course of any treatment I might be involved in, I would ask for my money back.

  8. Harmell, Pamela Hersh, "The Effects of Therapist Self-Awareness of Countertransference,", pp. 174ff.

  9. From the standpoint of the yogi, the "wounding" of the true psychic healer is not a one-time occurrence but is, rather, a continuous process wherein each new "illness" that is dealt with brings another wounding. This partly accounts for the yogi's frequent "illnesses." In the interplay between the patient and the therapist, this dynamic unfolds as the patient tries to work his or her problems out - projecting what he or she cannot bear onto the therapist in the effort to get its needs met, as it were. As a process it entails returning to the therapist again and again until, at a certain point, the process as a whole resolves.

  10. This same state is what the medical scientists call "sudden temporary nervous collapse and transient brain inhibition." Indeed, Robert Heath, a neurologist at the Tulane Medical School found that the experience of orgasm corresponds with a massive electrical discharge in the septal region of the limbic system, the brain's emotional center, located in the right or "primitive" part of the mind. It's no wonder boundaries dissolve, out of which arises the transcendent energy of "love."



    BIBLIOGRAPHY

    Bruyere, Rosalyn L. Wheels of Light; Chakras, Auras, and the Healing Energy of the Body. Edited by Jeanne Farrens. New York: Simon & Schuster!Fireside Books, 1994.

    Burkert, Walter. Greek Religion. transl. by John Raffan. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1985.

    Cavendish, Richard, ed. Man, Myth & Magic; The Illustrated Encyclopedia of Mythology, Religion and the Unknown, Volumes 8, 11, 12, 17, 19. Freeport, Long Island, NY: Marshall Cavendish Corporation, 1983.

    Doore, Gary, ed. Shaman's Path: Healing, Growth and Empowerment. Boston: Shambhala Press, 1988.

    Drury, Nevill. The Shaman and the Magician; Journeys Between the Worlds. London, Boston and Henley: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1982.
    ___Inner Visions: Explorations in Magical Consciousness. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1979.

    Eccles, John C. Evolution of the Brain: Creation of the Self. London and New York: Routledge, 1989.

    Evans, Arthur. The God of Ecstacy: Sex Roles and the Madness of Dionysus. New York: St. Martins Press, 1987.

    Guss, David M., ed. The Language of the Birds; Tales, Texts & Poems of Interspecies Communication. San Francisco: North Point Press, 1985.

    Harmell, Pamela Hersh, "The Effects of Therapist Self-Awareness on Countertransference" reprinted in Antioch University Los Angeles Course Reader: PSY 548 Professional Ethics and the Law, 2000.

    Hisey, Lehmann. Keys To Inner Space; An Open-Ended Guide to Occultism, Metaphysics and the Transcendental. New York: Avon Books, 1974.

    Hopcke, Robert and Karin Lofthus Carrington, & Scott Wirth, eds. Same-Sex Love And The Path To Wholeness; Perspectives On Gay & Lesbian Psychological Development. Boston: Shambhala, 1993.

    Jung, C.G. The Integration of the Personality. New York, Toronto: Farrar and Rinehart, Inc., 1939.

    Klein, Melanie and Riviere, Joan. Love, Hate and Reparation. New York, London: W.W. Norton & Company, 1964.

    Ornstein, Robert E. The Psychology of Consciousness. New York: Viking Press, 1972. ed. , The Nature of Human Consciousness; A Book of Readings. San Francisco: W.H. Freeman and Company, 1968.

    Rosenbaum, Robert A., Editor in Chief. The New American Desk Encyclopedia. New York: Concord Reference Books, 1984.

    Spence, Lewis. ed. An Encyclopedia of Occultism. New Hyde Park, New York: University Books, 1920 Reprinted 1960.

    Tart, Charles. "Preliminary Notes on the Nature of Psi Processes," The Nature of Human Consciousness; A Book of Readings. San Francisco: W.H. Freeman and Company, 1968.

    Thompson, Mark, ed. Gay Soul, Finding the Heart of Gay Soul and Nature. New York: HarpurCollins Publishers, 1994.
    ____Gay Spirit: Myth & Meaning. New York: St. Martin's Press, 1984.

    White, John and Stanley Krippner, eds. Future Science: Life Energies and the Physics of Paranormal Phenomena. Garden City, NY: Anchor Press, 1977.

    Winnicott, D.W. Through Pediatrics to Psychoanalysis: Collected Papers. New York: Basic Books, 1975

 

 

HOME
|
PRACTICE
|
WORKSHOPS
|
BACKGROUND
|
SELECT WRITINGS
|
WEB RINGS